Okay, there are three guys who put TigerBlog into a difficult spot Saturday night.
Andrew McMeekin. Coulter Mackesy. Ryan Croddick. All three are Princeton men's lacrosse alums. All three are in the Premier Lacrosse League.
McMeekin and Mackesy play for the Boston Cannons, who hosted the traveling PLL show this past weekend at Harvard Stadium. Croddick plays for the California Redwoods.
As far as the PLL goes, TB's rooting interest is in the Princeton players, at least one of whom can be found on each of the eight teams in the league. Perhaps TB can ask Dan Arestia, a lacrosse writer who seems to have answers to questions like this one, how many other colleges can make the same claim.
In fact, TB texted Dan that very question. As it turns out, Princeton is the only team with at least one player on every PLL team. UVa, Maryland and Duke have players on seven of eight.
Thanks Dan. He is the authority.
Meanwhile, back at the difficult spot from Saturday night, TigerBlog was faced with the dilemma of watching Croddick try to stop shots from Mackesy and McMeekin. What's someone like TB supposed to do with that?
When McMeekin wins a face-off forward, which he often does, the excitement of the play builds to see if he's going to shoot or not. There have been very few face-off specialists who can shoot it like McMeekin, by the way. That's ever, anywhere.
But wait. He's shooting on Croddick. The two are pretty much best buddies. They were teammates on Princeton's NCAA championship team this past spring.
And then there's Mackesy. TB has wanted every shot Mackesy has ever taken to go in the goal — and more of Mackesy's have done just that than those of any player in Princeton men's lacrosse history (167 of them, to be exact). But again. There's Croddick in goal.
That's unfair.
As it turned out, Boston won the game Saturday 12-9. Croddick came off the Redwoods bench to make eight saves while allowing five goals (one a two-pointer), and one of the goals he allowed was from Mackesy, who had two goals and one assist for the game.
The big story, quite possibly for the whole league this summer, has been the explosion of McMeekin on the pro game. The rookie who rewrote the face-off and groundballs sections of the Princeton record book has been dominant in the PLL, taking on some of the greatest face-off men ever to play the game and still leading the league in winning percentage (62.5 percent) and having more points (2G, 7A) than any other PLL face-off man this year.
This past weekend was maybe Meeks' best effort. In two games, both Cannons wins, his numbers were 32 for 51, with 20 groundballs, a goal and two assists.
The game Friday night was a 14-12 overtime win over the Whipsnakes. How'd they win by two in OT? The Whipsnakes got a stop but committed an interference infraction, giving the ball back to Boston. Rather than waiting for anyone to get set on either team, the Cannon's Marcus Holman simply drilled one into the vacated net. Game over.
Ah, but how did it get to overtime? Well, the answer is a little good fortune and a lot of Andrew McMeekin. The good fortune came when, with the score 11-10 Whipsnakes and a flag down against Boston, Maryland scored a goal just as the shot clock was going to expire, making it 12-10. Had Maryland not shot it there, then it still would be a one-goal game, but with slightly over a minute to play and a 60-second man advantage. The chances of running out the clock were pretty strong at that point.
Instead, the Whipsnakes took the goal, which actually was probably the only way Boston could win. McMeekin then won the face-off. Goal Boston. Another face-off win. Another Boston goal. OT. And then one more McMeekin face-off win.
McMeekin's two main opponents this weekend were Petey LaSalla and TD Ierlan. If you don't have the NCAA men's lacrosse record book as one of your bookmarks, then TB will tell you that that LaSalla ranks fourth and Ierlan ranks first all-time in Division I history in face-offs won.
McMeekin is third in the PLL in groundballs with 79, behind only Mike Sisselberger and Ierlan. Because of Princeton's long run to the NCAA title, McMeekin has played in only nine games this season, as opposed to the 12 for Sisselberger and the 11 for Ierlan. McMeekin, by the way, was 15 for 21 against Sisselberger in their head-to-head matchup, an 11-7 Cannons win over the Archers.
For some reason, McMeekin has managed to be a bit underrated his whole career, as TB has written before. His list of individual honors doesn't match up to his impact on Princeton's success during his time as a Tiger, which includes four NCAA tournaments, three Ivy tournament championships, five NCAA tournaments wins, one Ivy League title and of course the championship.
In all that time, McMeekin has never been first-team All-Anything. His biggest accolade was being named the Most Outstanding Player at the 2024 Ivy League tournament, an honor that came down to TB to select.
Will he be rewarded for the impact he's had on the Cannons and the rest of the league? Boston was 1-2 in the three games McMeekin didn't play to start the season. The team is 6-3 with him in the lineup and clinched its playoff spot this weekend.
Will he be the PLL Rookie of the Year? His three biggest challengers are all offensive players, including Princeton's Chad Palumbo (another best friend of the Croddick-McMeekin group), as well as Syracuse alum Joey Spallina and Utah alum Ryan Stines.
Palumbo leads all rookies with 20 goals, along with six assists (that's one fewer than McMeekin by the way). Spallina leads in rookie points with 34. Stines is second in rookie goals, assists and points (18-12-30).
Will McMeekin be PLL Rookie of the Year? He should be. No question.

